How to Spot a Bad Bathtub Refinishing Job (And What to Do About It)

A well-executed bathtub refinishing can breathe new life into your bathroom, offering a cost-effective alternative to replacement. However, not all refinishing jobs are created equal. Recognizing the signs of a subpar bathtub refinishing can save you time, money, and frustration. Here’s what to watch for and how to address these issues.

1. Sticky or Tacky Surface

A properly refinished bathtub should have a smooth, hard surface. If, after the recommended curing time, the tub feels sticky or tacky, it’s a red flag. This often results from improper application, inadequate drying conditions, or the use of low-quality materials.

Example: One individual reported that even after two days, their refinished tub remained sticky and showed visible paint runs, indicating an overly thick application (DIY Chatroom).

Solution: Contact the refinishing company immediately to assess and rectify the issue. If the problem persists, consider seeking a second opinion from another professional.

2. Peeling or Flaking Coating

Peeling or flaking a few short months after the resurface is completed is a common indicator of a poorly executed refinishing job. This can occur when the surface isn’t adequately prepared before application or when the coating is applied too thickly.

Example: A homeowner observed that the old paint wasn’t removed prior to refinishing, leading to visible bumps and subsequent peeling (Reddit).

Solution: Addressing peeling typically involves stripping the tub and reapplying the finish. Proper surface preparation is key to preventing this issue from recurring.  A correctly resurfaced tub can last well over 10 years.

3. Bubbles or Blisters

Bubbles or blisters on the tub’s surface suggest trapped air or moisture during the refinishing process. This not only affects the tub’s appearance but can also compromise its durability.

Solution: These imperfections usually require sanding down the affected areas and reapplying the coating. A meticulous refinishing professional can help avoid such issues.

4. Rough or Uneven Texture

A refinished bathtub should feel smooth to the touch. A rough or uneven texture may indicate contaminants on the surface during application or improper sanding between coats.

Solution: The tub may need to be sanded and recoated to achieve the desired smoothness. Ensuring a clean, dust-free environment during refinishing is essential.

5. Fading or Discoloration

Premature fading or discoloration can result from using low-quality materials or inadequate curing times. This not only diminishes the aesthetic appeal but can also signal underlying issues.

Example: Some homeowners have reported discoloration appearing within months, especially when harsh cleaning chemicals were used too soon after refinishing (This Old House).

Solution: Consult with the refinishing company to determine the cause and discuss potential remedies, which may include switching up your cleaning routine.

6. Strong, Lingering Chemical Odor

A professional refinishing job should not leave your bathroom with a harsh chemical smell for days on end. While refinishing products do have some odor, strong, lingering fumes could indicate the use of improper ventilation.  The resurfacing odor should not last longer than 24-48 hours, depending on the size of your home.

Example: Some refinishing products contain methylene chloride, a banned substance known for its toxic fumes, which can be harmful to inhale (EPA).

For more information read, “Why You Should Be Concerned For Your Health – The Dangers of Resurfacing.”

Solution: Ensure that your refinishing company uses low-VOC, eco-friendly coatings that minimize harmful odors and health risks.  Or opt for Tub Casting, which utilizes an odorless coating that is about 5x thicker than traditional refinishing.

Preventive Measures: Choosing the Right Professional

To avoid the pitfalls of a bad bathtub refinishing job, it’s imperative to select a reputable and experienced professional. Here are some tips to guide your decision:

• Research and Reviews: Look for companies with positive customer feedback and a proven track record.
• Experience: An experienced company is more likely to deliver a flawless finish and handle any challenges that arise.
• Quality of Materials: Ensure the company uses high-quality, durable materials designed for bathtub refinishing.
• Warranty: A confident professional will offer a warranty on their work, providing peace of mind.

By staying vigilant for these signs and taking proactive steps in selecting a qualified refinishing expert, you can ensure your bathtub remains a beautiful and functional centerpiece in your bathroom for years to come.